Bristol Greenbank Bowling Club, like many bowls clubs in Bristol, has
it origins within the industrial past of our city.
Clubs like G B Britton (Footwear), B.A.C. (Aerospace), Imperial (Tobacco), Bristol Arrow (Printing i.e. J W. Arrowsmiths), City & Port of Bristol (Shipping), Frys (Confectionary) and Bristol Omnibus (Transport) exist today and all began life by a company's reaction to the needs of its employees.
All of these clubs were formed within the last 115 years.
Other clubs such as Robinsons (Printing), Courage (Brewing) and National Smelting (Iron Trades) sadly no longer exist.
Bristol Greenbank, like Frys, was spawned from the confectionary industry. Indeed Mr H J Packer, the founder of the company on who's land our green was constructed, once worked for Frys but left to form his own business.
The early years of the Packers chocolate empire can be found by following the link at the bottom of this page.
Bristol Greenbank wish to convey their thanks to Elizabeth Shaw Chocolates who kindly allowed us to publish the following photographs of the times prior to and during the construction of the green.
We continue the story from 1923 onwards.
This photograph (taken from a periodical produced for the Packers workforce) shows the Packer Recreation Ground in 1923.
The caption below the photograph says " This fine photograph taken from the roof of the new No. 5 Block, gives a very good impression of the spaciousness of the ground, which has been described by an eminent Welfare authority as one of the finest and best equipped Industrial Recreation Grounds in England. The Imposing Institute, named after the late Mr. Bruce Cole, can be seen at the back. During the war, it served first to house a number of Belgian refugees, and afterwards as a Military Hospital. In the foreground the newly erected Tennis Courts show to great advantage. The cricket match in progress is the Gloucestershire v Sussex match. It may be mentioned that the ground has become the recognised venue for a number of Gloucestershire's home fixtures."
The land in the foreground of the photograph is part of the allotments referred to in the next paragraph, many of
which still exist today.
An article in the November/December periodical of 1924 appears to start the "bowl" rolling as it were for the implementation of the bowling green. The article says "Mr Clouter asked whether it would be possible to construct a bowling green for the use of the employees. A petition containing about 120 signatures had been submitted to the management. Mr. Crawford said that he recognised that a keen interest was being taken in this question by a very large section of the men. He pointed out that it would entail the giving up of a good many allotments, but he promised that the whole question would be most carefully considered."
It was not until the June/July of the following year when it was reported (in the periodical) that the green was to be constructed.
The article reports that:
The seed will probably be sown in the spring of 1926, as there is a great risk attached to autumn sowing should we have a severe winter. If we are as successful with the bowling green as we were with the tennis courts, we should be able to have the opening ceremony about the end of June or early July next year.
When the bowling green is finished we shall be in the happy position of having a recreation ground, which will provide sport for all who care to join, whether young or old, and no better appreciation of the Firms generosity can be shown than by making full use of the recreation facilities offered."
Action spoke louder than words it seems at Packers and in the August/September edition of the periodical photographs were published showing the construction of the green at a relatively advanced stage with no mechanical earth moving equipment in sight.
The photographs above showing the green under construction are taken from opposing diagonals. The view on the left is taken in the shadow of the No. 5 Block mentioned earlier. Just visible to the right are two men, one in a white coat, standing by the tennis courts, obviously discussing the progress of the project. In the background is the Institute. Less obvious are several workmen at work around the rear of the green as we view it. The view on the right shows the newish No. 5 Block with the tennis courts on the left. A workman in the centre leans on his spade for the photographer. A welcome break? To the right of him runs a pair of rails, no doubt an aid to help him move the soil etc. from the site. Planks of wood and levelling sticks appear to be the only aid when attempting to produce a surface that one day will be the "field of dreams" for so many bowlers.
November 1925 brought another statement in the periodical and things appeared to be moving on apace as a Bowls Club was proposed. The article read as follows:
The article reports that:
It was proposed and seconded that a club be formed, each member to find his own woods and
galoshes. This was carried
As a consequence of hard work and endeavour the bowls club was open for business in the spring of 1926 and thus became officially active on the opening of the green.
Part Two - The Early Years
Little is known of the early years of the H J Packer Bowls Club. We know that, in line with existing bowls clubs in the area, it had an official club badge
It is thought that the club existed for some six years under the H J Packer banner before becoming Bristol Greenbank Bowling Club. Somerset County records suggest that there may have been an existing Greenbank Bowls Club that amalgamated with the H J Packer Bowls Club. Membership of the Somerset County Bowling Association followed the amalgamation in 1932.
In 1933 Greenbank won the Bristol League Championship and were presented with the Christie Cup, a trophy that was to be retained for another two seasons.
In 1934 an even more prestigious cup was in the trophy cabinet, The Turnball Cup. As members of the Somerset County Bowling Association Greenbank were entitled to play in the county cup competition and thus became only the second team on the north side of the river Avon to become champions of Somerset, the first being St. George in 1932.
The following was published in a regional morning newspaper dated Wednesday 29th August 1934:
"TURNBALL CUP RIVALRY
The Turnbull Cup competitions is now nearing its close, and the final will be fought out by the holders, Ashcombe, Weston-super Mare and Greenbank, on
Saturday-week, September 8.
Subsequently the following was published in the same newspaper dated Monday 10th September 1934:
"TURNBULL CUP COMES TO BRISTOL
Greenbank Triumph by 13 Shots.
At the Victoria Bowling Green, Weston-super-Mare on Saturday, the Greenbank Club, Bristol made club history by winning the coveted Turnbull Cup for the
Bowlers from Bristol and throughout Somerset made up the large crowd of spectators which was treated to an interesting game the result of which was in doubt until the closing ends.
On the first rink the Greenbank men, skipped by E. Jones led until the twelfth end, when H. Kift's men then went ahead to finish with an advantage of three shots.
On the second rink F. Hewsons Bristolians went away from the start to play a great part in Greenbank's victory by gaining a 14 shot lead.
Play on the third rink went in favour of the Ashcombians, who led all the way to get a majority of nine.
But another substantial win came Greenbank's way on the fourth rink where E. W. Gosling's men took the lead at the start and finished 11 shots in front.
Mr E. M Trevor (county president) presented the trophy to Mr E. W. Gosling captain of Greenbank.
Messers Gosling J. Sheppard (president, Greenbank) T. G. Thomas (captain, Ashcombe) and A. E. Ateyo (president, Ashcombe) made short speeches.
The above poses the question "How did Bristol Greenbank and for that matter other Bristol Clubs be allowed to play for the Somerset County Cup and why are we now affiliated to Gloucestershire County Bowling Association?"
The following may go some way to explaining.
This account of the troubles that prevailed through 1936 and 1937 that follows, was kindly supplied by Graham Starr of Somerset County Bowls Association and is produced with his permission in its entirety.
The very first indication of a problem concerning Bristol Clubs and Somerset is found in the Minute from the EBA committee of 20th March 1915, wherein The Bristol Arrow Club was admitted to membership "subject to the English Bowling Association (EBA) consenting to their withdrawal from Gloucester County in favour of Somerset."
The next reference is a Minute from an EBA committee of 20th October 1919,
wherein the Secretary reported "correspondence with the Bristol Clubs who
desired to be attached to the Somerset District instead of the Gloucester
District because of the remoteness of the other clubs in Gloucester from the
City of Bristol, a section of the city forming part of Somerset geographically."
(This infers that Bristol Arrow had been allowed to transfer, and that other clubs wished to follow suit).
An EBA sub-committee of W N Lake, W H Ware and H K Fox of Gloucester (who had
attended the Somerset inaugural meeting), was appointed to report on the matter
with power to co-opt an equal number of Somerset & Gloucester players.
At the committee of 16th January 1920 it was reported that no action had been taken, and the Secretary was "authorised to determine the question."
Then the committee of 26th April 1920 was informed "that still no meeting of the sub-committee had taken place, either in Bristol or elsewhere, but as a result of correspondence the proposal was agreed to."
This is rather odd, because at the County Council meeting of 28th February 1920 i.e. before the EBA Committee, "the Secretary read correspondence from the EBA in which sanction was given to clubs in the Gloucester portion of Bristol to affiliate with Somerset County, but that they should be debarred from playing in the John Bull Competition. This was protested against by Mr Edbrooke of Bristol Arrow, and the Secretary was requested to write to the EBA with reference to same."
Just what did happen in early 1920?. No EBA sub-committee meeting, but a
decision by EBA on 26th April, although they had written to Somerset before 28th
February as the Minutes show. One possible explanation is that the EBA
Secretary having been "authorised to determine the question" took it upon
himself to say yes and reported as much to the next committee meeting, which
endorsed his decision. This would fit in with the County Secretary having
correspondence to read out at the 28th February Council, with the fact that
Bristol Arrow had been affiliated much earlier, and that immediately (at the
AGM of January 1921) no fewer than five Bristol Clubs were accepted as members of
A the same meeting, Mr Edbrooke queried the number of Bristol clubs applying for affiliation, and brought up the matter of a Bristol District. "This led to considerable discussion in the course of which Mr. Montague Cooper explained the rulings of the EBA, but on the suggestion of Mr W Wake that the discussion was out of place at this meeting, but that Bristol clubs had but to please themselves as to what action they took. The discussion dropped."
So, by the end of 1921, discussion had largely ceased and as the seasons went by, more and more Bristol clubs affiliated, so that by 1935 their number had risen to 22.
Then - at the AGM held on 23rd November 1935 there was trouble. A record attendance of 255 was noted, because Dr. R. Scott Reid of Bloomfield had put forward a Notice of Motion regarding Rule 3 (membership). There were objections to this on the grounds that such Motions should be brought by Clubs, not individuals. (The Bloomfield Club had mandated its delegates to support the Motion, although it's Minutes show that it felt the proposal was the Doctors and not the Clubs.)
Despite these misgivings, and after much discussion, the Motion was put to
"Membership of the Association shall be open to all bona-fide amateur bowling clubs and shall be confined to Clubs whose greens are geographically situated within the County of Somerset."
There was an immediate Amendment "that a joint meeting of representatives of both County Associations be called at an early date to discuss the Motion and refer it to the EBA for final decision." 107 voted for the Amendment and 120 were against. When the Motion was put to the meeting, 118 voted for it and there were 133 against, thus creating a status quo.
However, when the next business, namely the election of the President was
taken, neither E M Trevor or two other nominated gentlemen were willing to
stand. There must have been consternation at this point, and the Rev. S Crump of
Williton, obviously hoping to pour oil on troubled waters, proposed "that the
election of President be postponed to a special meeting, and that the AGM
proceed to other business". This did not appeal to the meeting, and after
discussion R Hamilton Bristol Arrow, proposed that the AGM be postponed until
18th January 1936 and that the present officers continue until that date. A Adey,
Bristol Tramways, seconded and the Motion was carried (Blessed are the
Hon. Secretary/Treasurer A E Morris tendered his resignation "but under pressure agreed to carry on until the adjourned AGM".
The Minutes continue "the Company were entertained by the President to tea. The annual supper and presentation of prizes followed". The general mood and ensuing conversations can only be imagined, but as this had been the first contentious meeting in the history of the Association, there can be little doubt that there were some lively discussions and arguments.
The adjourned AGM duly assembled on 18th January 1936. E M Trevor accepted the Presidency (although the voting was far from unanimous), A. E Morris of Bristol Arrow, confirmed his resignation and was immediately made a Vice President, and after election P J Parnell of Clarence Park emerged as the new Secretary/Treasurer. It can only be concluded that he subsequently, and soon, found himself in the deep end!
Doubtless many exchanges of view had taken place between the two meetings, and it was left to Ald. Reekes of the City of Wells club to propose:-
"that the decision at the meeting on November 23rd re. Bristol clubs in
Gloucestershire being affiliated be reconsidered."
The President ruled that the subject could be discussed but not voted upon. A lengthy discussion followed and it was ultimately agreed that the matter be referred to the EBA for their decision, and that the Secretary should write to them regarding the situation. Also agreed was the calling of a special meeting upon receipt of the EBA decision, attended by one delegate only from each affiliated club.
Secretary Parnell must have complied immediately, as the Minutes of the EBA Council meeting of 25th January refers to "a letter from the Hon. Secretary of SCBA....having been received" - that is a gap of only one week.
There is little point in reproducing the extensive EBA records of the discussions which ensued. Suffice to say that the question went through the Council, the Rules & Constitution Committee and two General Purpose Committees.
However it is worth noting the final and decisive words:-
"That the answer to the question referred to the EBA for decision from the adjourned AGM of the Somerset County Bowling Association (SCBA) held on the 18th January as to whether Bristol clubs whose greens are situated in the geographical area of Gloucester be entitled to belong to the SCBA be NO."
It is also interesting to observe that during these deliberations a separate
request " to alter the EBA Constitution to provide for a City & County of
Bristol becoming separately affiliated to the parent Association, as in the case
of the Isle of Wight" was thoroughly discussed and finally refused.
Furthermore, concern was expressed regarding the reaction of both the Bristol clubs and the Gloucester CBA and the Secretary was instructed to write to A E Morris of SCBA as representing the Bristol/Somerset clubs urging them to continue to affiliate to the EBA through Gloucestershire, and to Gloucestershire County Bowling Association asking it to sympathetically consider those clubs for affiliation.
The special meeting took place on 14th March 1936 at 3.00 pm. and was attended by the President, Past and Vice Presidents, and 45 delegates.
Secretary Parnell read his letter to EBA and their reply, which effectively brought the matter to conclusion. He reported that all clubs had been informed, and wishes that good friendship between Somerset & Bristol clubs were expressed on all sides.
Then at 4.00 pm. a meeting followed (presumably without the delegates from Bristol/Gloucester clubs), which altered the Rules of the Association to reflect the changes which had come about so rapidly, created a General Purpose Committee, together with the management structure which is basically still in place today, although radical changes are being considered for 2004 (not sure if these were implemented - Web Author).
It is reasonable to ask what caused all this to happen. The Minutes do not adequately reflect what must have been a fairly traumatic time, and the only source available in the search for background are the reports and letters in the local newspapers.
The Bath Chronicle and Herald reported the AGM in great detail, possibly
because a bowler from a Bath club had set the ball rolling with his Notice of
Motion regarding the Bristol clubs.
The speech with which Dr. Scott Reid presented his proposal is fully detailed and includes the phrases 'he had found much dissatisfaction and grumbling among Somerset clubs'-----'Everyone appeared to have a grievance of sorts'-----.The trouble in Somerset was the complete absence of unity and lack of proper county spirit'-----'That would never be restored before Somerset bowlers called Somerset County their own, and not a county which belonged to someone else'......'There was dissatisfaction among the smaller and lesser clubs of Somerset on account of the fact that they had been overlooked and more or less sacrificed in favour of vigorous and wealthier clubs. There were 22 Bristol clubs in Gloucester and 50 in Somerset.... it would balance up matters if the motion was agreed upon. The right and proper place for clubs was in the county to which they belonged.
Little wonder there was a debate lasting an hour & a half once the Motion had been tabled, and what a surprise that it finally failed by 15 votes!
The Weekly Bath Chronicle reported on President Trevor's speech on Thursday 28th November 1935 at Bloomfield Social. He obviously chose this occasion to nail his colours to the mast, given that it was Dr. Scott Reid's club. He used phrases such as "we shall, without doubt, by constitutional means get rid of what has become an incubus on this county"------ "They had refused to go decently, and now we will see that they go at all costs"------ We are losing 22 clubs - I think it is rather good sportsmanship on our side to do that, we are throwing away affiliation fees". He also stated his belief that the County was not well run, and indicated the need for changes in its administration.
Thus, some two years of increasing dissatisfaction, particularly selection, came to a head at that Bloomfield Social. Harmony could not possibly follow such widely reported words - from a man who was not only Somerset County President but also the EBA president. The outcome has been described earlier.
The fallout was predictable. Many bowlers on both sides expressed fervent and genuine wishes that good relationships should continue between clubs. J J Armer of Bristol St. Andrews wrote a diplomatic letter to the Western Daily Press expressing similar sentiments, and he it was who set in motion the series of meetings which resulted in the formation of the City & County of Bristol Bowling Association as we know it today.
The enduring nature of goodwill among bowlers is demonstrated by the fact that in 1937 the first of the continuing series of matches between Somerset County and the Bristol Association took place. These continued throughout the war, and in 1940 at Knowle B.C. the first game for the E M Trevor Cup was played.
Peace descended on the bowling scene, and today most bowlers know little or nothing of what happened during this short but eventful period.
Until now!!!! (Web Author)
Can YOU help us to research our clubs history? Please forward ANY information that you think would be of interest.
Follow the two links below for more on the Packer history. Then select the back button on your browser to return to this page.
Past Club Champions (Men's Section)
Past Club Champions (Ladies Section)